3.III.01 Devil's Playground 4

October 4th, 2010, 1:29 am

Author Comments:

Gibson Twist, October 4th, 2010, 1:29 am

Had a great time at Archon this weekend, and thanks again to everyone who was there, especially the folks from STL Webcomics for not only making it a great time, but for my new favourite game. To them, I say Like Water For Chocolate, The Dukes of Hazzard and almost all of the Harry Potter movies.

User Comments:

rainbowcrayon, October 4th, 2010, 1:34 am

*groans* My dad makes jokes like this all the time.

Jodie (Guest), October 4th, 2010, 2:19 am

i think it's because melanie is there

honestly their humor never sucked this bad until she arrived lol :p

artcurmudgeon, October 4th, 2010, 5:26 am

Black snake moan... :)

yayness (Guest), October 4th, 2010, 7:10 am

Vote incentive made me totally and utterly LOL :D They are three un-wise monkeys!

sentiashinou, October 4th, 2010, 7:22 am

It's a good thing that's Melanie and not Michelle or all of those guys would have gotten punched in the face like five times on this page.

Laura (Guest), October 4th, 2010, 7:29 am

O-oh, I detect residues of patriarchal prejudice! Maybe I'm a party-pooper, but I never tolerate more than two jokes of this kind from my male friends. Mostly because the girls never do the reverse kind.

They're nice guys, I guess, but maybe they could leave Melanie alone :/

darkamnios, October 4th, 2010, 7:58 am

That's one joke each.... I wonder if she would "joke" back with Andy and make the boy's jaw drop..

Gibson Twist, October 4th, 2010, 12:30 pm

Laura, you are indeed a party pooper. Jokes like these are never aimed or intended for a particular woman, just like "that's what she said" they are non-specific. At least, if they are being said about someone in particular, then that guy is a douchebag. Unlike "that's what she said", though, there's nothing patriarchal about this kind of joking, it is instead being juvenile and coarse and playing on words. It's easy to use 'er because -er is very common in English and there aren't as many words that use 'im. However, here are a couple examples I have used myself...

Tucker Brothers? I barely know 'er brothers!
Hocus Pocus? I barely know us!
Cherubim and serafim? I barely know 'im!

I would encourage anyone to play the game without ever referring to women, it's just not that easy. There may be patriarchal influences behind the ways some people recognize the game, but the game itself is pure.

Zhai, October 4th, 2010, 2:20 pm

*sigh* that's something I really recognise, my brother makes those sort of jokes all the time, and I make the kind of faces melanie makes xD

jchriselam, October 4th, 2010, 6:05 pm

Simple, not easy
It's ok for a Jewish comic to make jokes about Jewish people. It's not ok for us. Most people understand that.

Melanie can make jokes about women, the guys shouldn't. It's part of a bigger problem than bad manners.

It's ok for me to make jokes about gay men. It isn't ok for you.

If you don't get that, i can't explain it.


Durani, October 4th, 2010, 6:32 pm

I am truely not into many "real life" type webcomics. Mostly my favourites WC's are looking for group and other similiar fantasy ones. But PoY has gripped me by the heart and not let go, i've read up to here over the past few weeks and will check it every single day. :D

Gibson Twist, October 4th, 2010, 7:11 pm

Actually, I make jokes about gay men all the time and the gay men who are my friends laugh. I make jokes about women too, and Jews and blacks and the Irish, and I've done it all in this comic, but the many gay, female, Jewish, black and/or Irish readers that I have are still reading. The quality of my writing determines whether people are offended, and many things determine the quality of my writing. I'm a white, heterosexual male without religious affiliation, and the day I can't write humourously about people who aren't is the day they stop appearing in my work.

And holy shit, how boring would that be? I have more respect for social minorities than to think they have less a sense of humour about themselves than I do about myself. Confusing friendly ribbing with malicious bigotry is what makes the malicious bigotry harder to kill.

You can make jokes about gay people not because you're gay, but because you know how to tell gay jokes without hurting gay people.

MAMA LUIGI, October 4th, 2010, 7:39 pm

Well, me and my friends are all girls and we make jokes even worse than this.
People need to chill, it ain't that big of a deal...

Sly Violet (Guest), October 4th, 2010, 8:00 pm

No--It's pretty funny!
Mind you I love cheesy humor, but I am, gasp, a woman and I chuckled at this (and the fart clouds). By doing that in no way do I feel I need to trade in my membership cards to the various leftist movements that are killing America.

Actually, I must say I got quite livid when I read the reactionary, um, reactions. I calmed down, but I still gotta get a bit out.
I can't agree more that Pavlovian responses to "red flag" words and phrases does nothing but hurt the quest for a better world, not only diluting the righteousness behind calling-out serious hate speech, but also making it harder to discern the most insidious bigotry, the subtle kind.

The serpent was subtle. The most effective evil always is.

Also, as a woman who regularly engages in this kind of juvenile (I admit it's juvenile) behaviour with her friends, I myself felt a little bit personally reactionary to the high-horse/bum-hurt responses. My first response would have been very caustic, indeed, had I not stopped for a minute.

Ultimately, for me it's like this, though: as much as I want to defend this with as much passion as I can muster, and get into a big hoopla, I won't.
Why? Because I don't get all bum-hurt every time this comic doesn't reflect my life/opinions. Ultimately this is a story of characters so well-written that they seem real. As long as they are acting in a way that reveals their character, the good the bad and the cheesy, what can I say? This is what good art is, it makes you mad and happy, it makes you see the flaws of your friends and the humanity of your enemies. This is a good thing.

I'll save my anger for bad writing, should it ever appear (anything's possible).

I fear we may not see such verisimilitude as much as we could, do the fear of offense, esp. in media where profit is important. I think that's sad.

It's always interesting, these periodic debates on here. Since I already typed a novel, I may as well say one last thing: I love reading the responses, and even with the above, it wasn't the opinion that bothered me (so much) but the idea of removing words from their context/making some words off-limits for some people is about the most chilling thing this side of double speak.

Guest, October 4th, 2010, 8:18 pm

You're my brother, I'll make fun of you because I love you. Anyone who doesn't love you makes fun of you, I'll kill them.

xkrazydog, October 4th, 2010, 8:45 pm

those jokes 8| ....... I dont quite get them. Is this bad?

sIck, October 4th, 2010, 9:41 pm

How could anyone even be offended by a type of joke like this? I don't even understand the offensive part of it. It's aimed "against" women? Or what? ... And even if it was aimed at a particular woman, it still sounds just like junior high school teasing.

Great page, haha, the facial expressions say SO much. XD

max (Guest), October 5th, 2010, 2:52 am

Rectum? Damn near killed 'im!

Tsuki (Guest), October 5th, 2010, 3:15 am

Hear, See, and Speak all Evils
Love the incentive XD

Burninator, October 5th, 2010, 8:01 am

where's the lengthy analysis?
I'm missing jd_singer's long post comic analysis with links to old comics and such. Where is he?

Post A Comment


Original Design by kingv
Redesign by Gibson Twist
Archive Design by Enkida
and Trenton Dawn
Editing and Immeasurable Assistance by Rori!

Hosted proudly by